236 Council in the Ali Imam regime. We saw a good deal of each other and got an insight into much that could not be reached from the office table; while our literary tastes and meditative propen- sities brought us still closer together. It was a wrench when we parted towards the end of 1922, on his deciding to go back to the place of his domicile and the post of higher duty. I had the pleasure of meeting him again after some years in 1935 at Mecca during the Haj, and afterwards at Jeddah. At Mecca I was able to look farther along the avenues of his mind which in spite of his English habits, had led him to the home of faith; and I found that his heart was kept constantly open to receive inspiring suggestions from the historic associations of the Sacred City. In this way the commentary on the Qur'an which he was shaping in his mind, was gradually gathering beams of the pristine light emanating from the Kaaba. Knowledge of his inner nature convinced me that a man like him, if lost to the country as an official, is regained as a far more useful worker in a higher sphere, where the nature of the service is purer and more exalted and its effects more lasting and more beneficial. If he had remained on with us as Revenue Minister, could he have done any- thing of equal value ? But I regret his absence from Hyderabad for a different reason ; a mind like his would have exerted on our young men a wholesome influence on the educational and cultur- al side. And, further, he would have served as