208 He was a personal friend of my father and uncle and I am glad to say that in my early official career I had the opportunity of cultivating his 'acquaintance when I was serving as Under-Secret- ary in the Legislative Department. We met frequently at committee meetings to discuss drafts of bills and he came to have in course of time an opinion of me that induced him to offer me the Revenue Secretaryship. It was a great com- pliment to a junior officer, as I then was, and I felt flattered by it, but I excused myself on the ground that my career lay in the Judicial IJepart- ment. I once took the liberty of suggesting to Mr. Dunlop the desirability, not to say the urgent need, of having the multifarious revenue gashtis which were in a state of confusion, reduced to an orderly and compendious form. And I further pointed out to him how necessary it was to have a definite procedure followed in revenue cases and to have some finality in the decisions. I remember that he got a committee appointed to go into these matters and I can even recall the name of one of them, Moulvi Abdul Qader (afterwards Qader Nawaz Jung), but what the committee actually achieved and what the result of its recommenda- tions was, I do not know. His Highness the late Nizam was pleased to put Mr. Dunlop in charge of the management of the Salar Jung estate during the minority of the present Nawab Salar Jung. It is said that the estate was managed well under his control and