155 and engaging manners, learned (according to the standard of the times) in Arabic aud Persian, quick-witted and with a sparkle of arch humour in his eyes, and a persuasive speaker As a writer he had attracted some attention by his Ayat-e- Baiyya- nat, a treatise in refutation of the Shia doctrine, based upon Quranic texts. He seemed to be well qualified by his talents to take a prominent place and shine in any society, both in private and public life. It was said of him, that by his fine ' promising manner' of listening to peoples' requests he always sent them away satisfied! There is an amusing anecdote about his peculiar humour. Some man from the North once came to seek employment and was received by Moulvi Saheb with his usual courtesy and asked to take a seat. After a few minutes he was introduced to those present with • the remark : "This gentleman is one before whose • ancestors mine have sometimes bowed their heads/ It became known afterwards that the person referred to was descended from a barber ! Men seeking employment were coming in increasing numbers in those days—and this was beginning to be resented by the people of Hyderabad. The Mulki Non-Mulki question was formulating itself. Moulvi Mehdi Ali Khan became Political and Financial Secretary under the Second Sir Salar Jung and was given the title, Nawab Munir Nawaz Jung and some years later he became Nawab 'Mohsin-ul-Mulk, "benefactor of.the country/' He continued in this office when Sir Asman Jah became